Fan blades replacement

-
I have two fans at home, one of them is quieter than the other. I assumed the reason was the shape and number of the blades, as the noisier one features a 3-blade rotor while the quieter one is a 5-blade one. 

A good design exercise that might bring some real-life benefit if proved successful. So I went on and created a model using Onshape, that had to be able to be printed in the Prusa MINI. I designed two parts, the hub, and the blade, that will join with a dovetail. 

While I did not do an exact copy of the quieter fan blades, I tried to stay as similar as possible. Which may not be good enough for the best results.

It was also a project to explore the viability of the 3D printed approach. So this is what I designed: 

To my amazement, 3D printing the blades really favored printing them all together, as the print time of each layer was so small if printing just one that the print needed to be slowed down. So printing five blades did only required around 3 times the print time of printing a single one.  In fact, the whole six pieces could be fitted into the print bed of the MINI. But in my case, I did want to use a different color for the hub, so I printed the hub and the blades separately. 



I used a supports-blocker for the supports not to creep into the sides of the dovetail to make sure it will slide gently in place. I added a 0.2 mm clearance into the designed which allowed and nice pressure fit of the components.


But although I was pleasantly surprised by the tight fit and the good looks of the parts, the final result was not a complete success. The fan still did its job of moving the air but not in a significantly quieter way as I was expecting, so I will not call this a success. 


On the plus side now I know how to fix a fan with broken blades :-)

I would love to hear from you in the comments below if you can shed some light on the matter of fan blades and noise. Maybe a different blade design, maybe some winglets, can make a difference ...

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

VFD control with Arduino using RS485 link

-
Image
Variable Frequency Drives ( VFD ) allow the control of spindles so speed can accurately be controlled and a detailed acceleration profile for the spindle and reverse rotation can all be handled. In essence a VFD is an three phase inverter for three-phase AC motor. I am using a popular (I mean cheap) Chinese VFD and though the reference manual is not great, I could see there is a built-in RS-485 port. I usually control the start, stop and speed selection using the keyboard on the unit but I thought it will be more useful if I could control everything from the same Arduino is doing our CNC table control. Some cheap RS-485 off eBay and some lines of code later, I can start, stop and change the speed from an Arduino. What a cool thing to have! Some configuration of your VFD are needed before you can use it like that.  You need to set PD163=1 (I am using address 1 in the code). PD=164=1 (for setting serial to 9600bps) and PD165=0 (for using ASCII and 8N1 character format)
Read more

How to get sinusoidal s-curve for a stepper motor

-
Image
After some experimentation, and delving a bit into the math of motion, I realized there can be a significant difference on the motion of a machine by just making small changes. A common and popular approach to smooth one axis of motion is to use a trapezoidal speed pattern, where acceleration and deceleration are uniformly accelerated movements (aka constant acceleration motion) separated by a portion happening at cruising speed. The problem comes with the fact that, while that approach is simple to understand and to code, it does contain sudden changes in the acceleration, that show as spikes on the acceleration derivative, called jerk. These sudden changes in the acceleration translate into undesired vibration in our machines. Most of that can be eliminated by selecting a motion pattern that does not contain sudden changes of acceleration. If we chose a mathematical function for our speed whose second derivative is continuous, then we reduce system vibration quite a lot. One ma
Read more

Stepper motor step signal timing calculation

-
Image
While we use stepper motors in many devices, the timing of the step signals is not always well understood. Most of us can see how a fixed speed is a bad idea unless the speed of motion is really slow, but it is fixed speed what is really to generate with simple code. You just can use the Arduino Blink example to send a fixed frequency of pulses to a stepper motor driver. If too slow, just reduce the delay value. But for most real-life applications variable speed controls will perform better. These systems will speed up the motor to a given maximum speed and it will slow it down to stop at the desired step count. But understanding the math behind this process is sometimes not obvious. Let us start with the simple case of the so-called trapezoidal speed motion profile. Here motion takes place in three phases: acceleration, constant speed (cruising) and deceleration. But the point is how can our code create such a behavior. Stepper motor drivers usually accept two signals to control
Read more